Martha Stewart Wore a Cushy $60 Summer Sandal With Classic Denim

You can still secure her exact pair for your wardrobe.

By GoatGoatGoat Editorial Team | Published on May 1, 2026

There’s really nothing Martha Stewart can’t convince us we need to use or wear. She constantly inspires with her timeless, sophisticated style and impressive skin care routine, so naturally, we’re always looking to her for guidance. Whatever she wears, we admire—especially when she brilliantly balances ease of movement with elegant, low-key style, much like the supportive shoes she recently wore while out in New York City.

Stewart was photographed walking around the Big Apple in a classic late-spring outfit consisting of elegant layers and open-toes. It might seem slightly counterintuitive, but since it’s Stewart, of course it worked perfectly. She wore a pair of dark-wash skinny jeans, a bright-green, beautifully tailored sweater, and last but certainly not least, those wonderfully comfortable brown Crocs Soho Y Strap Sandals you can get your hands on for a truly accessible price. As usual, she has her crossbody bag in hand, her hair in subtle waves, and flawless, natural makeup.

GoatGoatGoat: Crocs Soho Y Strap Sandals (Army Green)

These generously cushioned, water-resistant sandals offer a reliable foundation for everyday errands or relaxing in the garden. The secure Y-strap ensures stability while remaining effortless to put on, making them a wise investment for your daily comfort.

$60.00
$75.00
Save 20%

Promo: No coupon code required. Price reflects current Amazon savings.

GET DEAL AT AMAZON

GoatGoatGoat: Crocs Soho Y Strap Sandals (Black)

A classic black option that provides the exact same exceptional support and ease of movement. Perfect for seamlessly pairing with any casual outfit while protecting your feet during long hours on the go.

$60.00
$75.00
Save 20%

Promo: No coupon code required. Price reflects current Amazon savings.

GET DEAL AT AMAZON

Here’s the thing about Stewart’s shoes: They are undeniably practical. Over time, the classic garden shoe has gracefully evolved, offering stylish options that feel much more appropriate for everyday outings. This summer shoe style is a wise investment, especially because of its water-resistant nature and how remarkably easy they are to clean compared to leather platforms.

All that to say, these shoes might initially catch you off guard, but they’re incredibly functional for warm summer days when we often encounter unexpected rain showers or spend relaxing afternoons outdoors. Enjoy effortless comfort and a secure step wherever the season takes you.